The Top 10 NCAA Football Cover Athletes—Ranked All-Time From ultra-rare editions to iconic stars—here are the most memorable faces ever featured on NCAA Football covers

EA Sports' NCAA Football franchise may be dormant, but its cultural impact endures—especially through its iconic cover athletes. Fox Sports compiled a list of the Top 10 cover stars who defined the era. Here's a reimagined look at their rankings and why they matter.

🏈 The Countdown: Top 10 NCAA Cover Athletes

1. Herschel Walker (NCAA Football 2005) The final star of the franchise stands out both on the field and in cultural memory. His cover marked the end of an era—and remains rare among collectors.

2. Tim Tebow (NCAA Football 2007) The Florida legend brought national glory and Heisman-worthy hype. His larger-than-life persona made his cover one of the most iconic.

3. Peyton Manning (NCAA Football 1998) One of the few Big Ten quarterbacks to earn a solo cover, celebrating his Kentucky to Tennessee journey and a rising star in college football.

4. Tom Brady & Charles Woodson (NCAA Football 2000) The only dual cover ever released—reflecting Woodson’s college dominance and Brady’s emerging leadership before his NFL legend was born.

5. Ron Dayne (NCAA Football 1999) The Wisconsin workhorse became the first Big Ten player featured solo—recognized for his relentless power running and Heisman trophy momentum.

6. Marcus Allen & Reggie White (NCAA Football 1996) Featuring both a running back and a defensive icon—acknowledging the franchise’s appreciation for two-way college greatness.

7. Ricky Williams (NCAA Football 1999) Texas' dynamic back delivered spectacular visuals and NCAA legend status—making his cover one of the most memorable for the era.

8. Desmond Howard (NCAA Football 1995) Capturing the Heisman image that’s forever tied to his iconic punt return against Michigan—still a standout cover.

9. LaDainian Tomlinson (NCAA Football 2001) The Chargers star in the making sourced the franchise’s nod to explosive running style and precise field vision.

10. Doug Flutie (NCAA Football 1993) Heisman hero of the early ‘90s whose magic moments — culminating in the "Hail Mary" — launched him to nostalgic cover fame.

---

🔍 Why These Covers Still Matter

• They symbolize eras, capturing each athlete at a defining career moment
• Limited runs and regional exclusivity make certain covers collectible—and historic
• Many athletes went on to legendary NFL success, strengthening the link between NCAA Football and NFL legacy
• They remind fans of the lost franchise's cultural footprint and its role in immortalizing college moments

---

✅ TL;DR

• The Top 10 NCAA Football cover athletes include giants like Herschel Walker, Tim Tebow, Peyton Manning, and Tom Brady.
• Some athlete selections were solo covers, others paired—emphasizing legendary college success and market relevance.
• These cover stars continue to resonate with fans nostalgic for the franchise’s heyday.